Friday 25 February 2022

The British Floridas. 1763-1784. Part 4

Initial Suggestions On Some Landowners

My research shows the problem of identifying particular individuals, but indicates possible starting off information on which further research is needed.

Dudley Ackland. Was he the soldier in the West Indies in 1769 and Colonel of the Shropshire Volunteers in the West Indies from 1779 to 1784?

Christopher Baldwin. Was he the plantation owner on Antigua and Dominica who settled on Clapham Common West Side where he built the Grange in 1762?

Robert Bremner. Was he the Scottish music publisher?

Thomas Bridges. Was he the English writer of parodies, drama and one novel born in Hull?

John Callander. Could he be the  Scottish antiquarian  whose book Terra Australis Cognita, or Voyages to the Southern Hemisphere during the Sixteenth, Seventeenth, and Eighteenth Centuries published between 1776 and 1778 promoted colonisation?

Walter Thomas Chittick. Was he the doctor who lived in London, who subscribed to John O’Rouke’s A Treatise on the Art of WarOr, Rules for Conducting an Army in All the Various Operations of Regular Campaigns(1778), and George William Lemon’s English EtymologyOr, a Derivative Dictionary of the English Language (1783)?

Francis Rush Clerk. Was he the Inspector and  Supplier of the provision of wagons and horses during the American Rebellion, commenting in detail in 1776 and 1777 on the inadequacies of what had been supplied?

John Dunning. Was he the lawyer who was MP for Calne between 1768 and 1782 who died as Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancashire?

William Faden. Was he the London based publisher of The Public Ledger and The North American Atlas in 1777 chronicling the American Rebellion’s  battles?

Neighbour Frith. Was he the London silk merchant who built Woolet Hall (now Loring Hall) in Bexley?

Pierce Galliard. Was he the barrister at law who lived in Bury Hall in Edmonton and Bradshaw Hall in Eyam in Derbyshire, who had extensive land interests in Derbyshire, Middlesex, Essex, and Burford  including mining interests in Edmonton and  Eyam, and was involved in a complex marriage settlement indenture involving a number of Earls?

Caleb John Garbrand and Nathaniel Hone. Could they be the painters? 

John Hincks. Could he be the Chester merchant and sugar maker, who in the late 1750s was a partner with Joseph Manesty, the Liverpool slave trader, and purchased coal from the Neston Collieries for his refinery?

Captain John Jervis. Could he be the Royal Navy officer who later became Viscount St. Vincent and whose sister married William Henry Ricketts (see above)?  

Baker John Littlehales. Could be the man who lived in Moulsey in Surrey?

William Mcbean. Could he be the man who left an estate in Jamaica when he died in 1780?

George Moore. Could he be the London merchant who shipped out convicts to Maryland in 1783 at the request of the Government?

Walter Radcliffe. Could he be the man painted by SirJohsua Reynolds, who  owned Warleigh House in Devon now owned by the National Trust?

John Gilpin Sawrey. Could he be the owner of Broughton Tower in Lancashire who died in 1773 living in Middlesex?

John Sinclair. Could he be Sir John Sinclair of the Board of Agriculture, who recorded in his memoirs that William Dunn of East Florida had written to request a ‘style of culture most adapted to a sandy soil’and who believed that James Macpherson took his Gaelic Poems of Oassian writings with him to West Florida to be Governor Johnson’s  surveyor-general?

Benjamin Stichall. Could he be the London based bookbinder, who was joint publisher of Mark Catesby’s 1754 The Natural History of Carolina, Florida, and the Bahama Islands?

Florida Landowners And Emancipation Compensation

A few of the 24 people recorded on the Legacies of British Slave-Ownership database with Florida connections were involved there at the time of British rule:  Dr James Dallas, Thomas Dunnage , Sir Archibald Grant, the 3rd Bart. of Monymusk, and Harry and Thomas Hackshaw.

Sir Archibald Grant may be either the Scottish father or son. The father was expelled as an MP for fraud in 1732. He involved in mines in Derbyshire and Scotland. Either one or both of them  became involved in owning a plantation on Jamaica.

Thomas Dunnage was a London merchant, who invested with Francis Phillipe Fatio and John Francis Rivas in the New Castle plantation in 1770. It was renamed New Switzerland. Dunnage also purchased annuities from the owners of plantations on Nevis and Antigua. Fatio was a Swiss merchant who had settled in London about 1757. They spent £2,430 to buy 18 enslaved Africans to develop the estate and then a further £2,570 up to 1776. Rice and orange trees were grown. Pine was felled for naval and timber supplies. Fatio and his family moved to St. Augustine to manage the plantation. In 1774 he moved with his family to  New Switzerland River. It grew sweet and sour oranges, citrons and lemons. In 1778 partner Rivas purchased 5,000 acres next to New Switzerland.

Landowners And  The Enslaved After The Floridas Were Returned To Spain

Presumably written before the hand back to Spain 1784 saw the publication of Thomas Hutchins’s An historical narrative and topographical description of Louisiana, and West-Florida.

After the return of the Floridas to Spain the British and the loyalists were mainly relocated to other parts of the British Americas particularly the Bahamas. A few stayed under Spanish rule like Jesse  Fish.

 

It took sometime for the British evacuation to be completed. Prior to the transfer of the  slaves on the Ceciliton Plantation to Dominica in early 1785 a survey listed 78 belonging to the heirs of Lord Egmont, and 22 owned by  Stephen Egan. In the first few weeks of the year Egan sold lumber and naval stores for £708. 

The Egmont and Egan enslaved labourers arrived ill at Dominica .They were rented to other planters, primarily clearing land and planting coffee trees, and the Egmont enslaved were sold in September 1786 netting £3,648.

The transfer back to Spain of the Floridas took from 1783 to 1785 created severe problems. Tonyn had to deal with a mutiny of the local troops, who agreed to go to Nova Scotia, and combat the pillaging of plantations. He also had to negotiate with the now independent South of Carolina government over the return of property, mostly slaves, taken  to East Florida by the loyalists. One group owned by Colonel James Cassells went back to South Carolina by choice not wanting to go to  the Bahamas as he planned.

Although  Fort St. Augustine was handed over in July 1784, Governor Tonyn remained until November 1785.

In the end nearly 10,000 people left East Florida. departed. 3,247 including 2,200 slaves went to the Bahamas; over 3,000 including nearly 2,600 slaves to the United States, about 900 to Nova Scotia, and about 900 (mostly slaves) to Jamaica. Some went to England like Captain John Gaillard, Colonel Elias Ball, and the former customs officer John Morgridge. William Moss, resettled his enslaved labourers in the Bahamas. His correspondence was published in 1854.

Many of the original settlers from England also set off for the Bahamas like Francis Levitt, junior with his goods, 100 slaves, house frames and household silver. He had to leave a lot behind because the ship was too small. Unsuccessful in the  Bahamas he returned to London. Later he went to Georgia. Henry Laurens helped him set up set Sea Island cotton plantation.

For Jesse Fish because a large number of the estates reverted to the Spanish Crown. He lost most of his land holdings. He had accumulated large debts in St. Augustine and Cuba. He moved back to Britain in 1784 and lived at Aston Hall in Shropshire. This was the home of his wife Eleanor’s father George Austin. Austin had been to Carolina developing tobacco plantations and slave trading. He was partner with Henry Laurens, returning to England in 1762 after a disagreement. Fish continued to hold Santa Anastasia Island, forty houses and lots, and six other tracts of uncultivated land near St. Augustine. His buildings were described by observers as being in advanced stages of decay. In 1786-7 is known to have had 17 slaves working his plantation.

Fatio decided to become a Spanish citizen and  renamed New Switzerland as Nueve Suiza. He was appointed with John Leslie of Panton, Leslie & Co to judge disputes between the British who were leaving, including over taking their slaves with them. He bought their estates cheaply. He bought out his partners to become sole owner of the plantation, and auctioned off remaining common property including 50 slaves including sawyers, squarers, field labourers and a cooper, a cook, a house servant.

Moultrie  returned to Britain in 1784. Three of his brothers fought with the Americans in the Rebellion. He lived at Aston Hall in Shropshire which had been the home of his father-in-law George Austin who had developed tobacco plantations in Carolina and been involved in slave trading along with Henry Laurens. Moultrie is buried in Shifnal Church.

In 1790 an author named Zetes published An address to the Parliament and people of Great Britain, on the past and present state of affairs between Spain and Great Britain, respecting their American possessions published in 1790. He reviewed the history of treaties between the two countries, including the period of British control of the Floridas. He regarded the Spaniards as untrustworthy anticipating war’

Economic Effects On British Economy

 

We do not know how much British capital was invested bythose granted  land  in the Floridas, the scale of the imports and exports, the level of profits and losses, nor  what any profits were spent on back in Britain or in other Caribbean colonies.  It also seems likely that more was spent in East Florida by the Government than was covered by the taxes raised in the colony. This is probably partly due to the cost of defending the colony from the American rebels , including the stationing of troops.

Further Research

 

Further work on the British planters would make  for an interesting PhD thesis. As well as the British Privy Council (Colonial), the Houses of Commons Lords Papers and other documents providing information about the land grants and the administration of the Floridas, and the East Florida Claims Commission papers at The National Archives (T77) and related papers listed on the Commission page. There is a detailed listing of the TNA East Florida Colonial Office papers by David Swain (2014).There is  a wealth of information in US Congress papers. There are articles in journals such as the Florida State Historical Quarterly, Louisiana Historian, and Legal History. There are  contemporary books by authors like James Grant Forbes and later authors such as Walter Henry Sickert, S. Max Edelson, Robert R. Ree, and Charles Loch Mowat. There are also Florida History Online, Legacies of British Slave-ownership database, British History Online, The History of Parliament, the Hallowes Genealogy website and last year William Bruce Antliff’s  American Loyalists claims up on Global Heritage Press’s website. A few surviving wills like that of James Fortrey  of Ely at The National Archives may tell us something.

Select Bibliography

Kenneth H. Beeson. Fromajadas and IndigoThe Minorcan Colony in Florida. Arcadia Publishing. 2006

Christopher C. Booth. Robert Willan and His Kinsmen. Medical History. Vol. 25(2) April 1981. pp. 181–196

Pete Wilson Coldham. American Migrations, 1765-1799. Genealogical Publishing Company. 2011

Dictionary of Canadian Biography

David Dobson. Scottish Emigration to Colonial America, 1607-1785. University of Georgia Press. 2004  

Carrita Doggett. Dr. Andrew Turnbull and The New Smyrna Colony of Florida. The Drew Press.1919 & Founders Publishing Co.1994  

S. Max  Edelson. The New Map of EmpireHow Britain Imagined America before Independence. Harvard University Press. 2017

S.Max Edelson. Plantation Enterprise in Colonial South Carolina.  Harvard University Press. 2011

The Elkton Hastings Historic Farmstead Survey, St. Johns County, Florida

Robin F. A. F tel. The Economy of  British West Florida 1763-1763. University of Alabama Press. 2002

James Grant Forbes. Sketches, Historical and Topographical, of the Floridas: More Particularly of East Florida. C.S. Van Winkle. 1821

Douglas Hamilton.  Scotland, The Caribbean and the Atlantic World, 1750-1820. Manchester University Press. 2010

David Hancock. Citizens of the World: London Merchants and the Integration of the British Atlantic Community, 1735-1785. Cambridge University Press. 1997

Paul E. Hiffman. Florida’s Frontiers. Blackwell. 2001

Cecil Johnson. British West Florida 1763-1783. Yale University Press.1943 & Archan Books. 1971

Katharine A. Kellock. Stephen Collins, Philadelphia Merchant. Business Archives. No.  36. June 1972

Robert Stansbury Lambert. South Carolina Loyalists in the American Revolution. Journal of American History. Vol. 75(3). December 1988. p. 919–920

Bruce Lenman. Britain’s Colonial Wars 1688-1783. Routledge. 2001

Arlin C. Migliazzo. To Make this Land Our OwnCommunity, Identity, and Cultural Adaptation in Purrysburg Township, South Carolina, 1732-1865. University of South Carolina Press. 2007.

Charles Mowat. East Florida a a British Province 1763-1784. University of California Press. 1943

James W. Rabb. Spain, Britain and the American Revolution in Florida, 1763-1783. McFarland. 2008

Robert R. Rea. Military Deserters from British West Florida. Louisiana History. Vol. 9(2). Spring 1968

Marjorie Marjorie Rear. William Barker Member of The Right Worshipful Levant Company 1731-1825. A Life In Smyrna. www.levantineheritage.com/pdf/Biography-of-William-Barker-Levant-Company-Merchant-Marjorie-Rear.pdf

Patrick Riorden. Finding Freedom in Florida: Native Peoples, African Americans and Colonists, 1670-1816. The Florida Historical Quarterley. Vol. 75(1). Summer 1996

George C. Rogers. The East Florida Society  of London 1766-1767. The Florida Historical Quarterly. Vol 54(4). April 1976

Daniel L. Schafer. Plantation Development in British East Florida: A Case Study of the Earl of Egmont. Florida Historical Quarterly. Vol. 63(2). 1984

John C. Shields & Eric D. Lamore. New Essays on Phillis Wheatley. University of Tennessee Press. 2011

Walter Henry Sickert..Loyalists in East Floria 1774-1785. Florida State Historical Society. 1929

Wilbur H. Siebert. The Port of St. Augustine During the British Regime. Florida Historical Quarterly. Vol. 24. 1945

Wilbur H. Siebert. Slavery in East Florida. Florida Historical Quarterly. Vol. 10(3).1931

Erin Thursby. Florida Oranges.  A Colorful History. Arcadia Publications. 2019.

Spencer C Tucker. (ed.) American Revolution: The Definitive Encyclopaedia and Document Collection. ABC Clio. 2019

 

 

No comments:

Post a Comment